
Diesel hatches are quite a popular option these days. Take the case of the Swift, which enjoys a waiting period of two months, it is now almost worth its own weight in gold. Hyundai has been working on a diesel Getz with a 1.1L engine too, but recently they realized that by the time they could get it rolling, everyone will be driving a swift. Something has to be done quickly to grab their piece of pie. So in a bit of a hurry, they went back to the insides of the company store room and took a look at all the diesel engines lying around. They couldn’t find anything small enough for the Getz, so they decided to shoe-horn the Verna’s rather big 1.5L engine into the tiny bonnet of the Getz. So the end result is a Getz that looks like a Getz and goes like a Verna and handles like something in between. But will it be able to make a dent in the thriving sales of the Maruti Swift?To find out, we brought them together for a duel so that you don’t have to. Now, at this moment I must admit that almost all the car magazines have done this comparison test before us and come up with a winner except for OVERDRIVE magazine who came up with two. They said ‘the Swift is quite good but if you can spend more, the Getz is good too’. Where is the point? Anyone can say that by looking at the price list. So we didn’t give any of them an ear and went on with our test, to pick one car that can better the other.Looks are subjective but I could not differ when almost everyone said the Swift looks better than the Getz. It is now a popular sight almost everywhere, but still the design has got its own charm. The Getz has a much more restrained design and is more appreciated by elder folks who think that the Swift is too youthful and modern. But when it comes to the interiors, the Getz can rival many a larger sedans, let alone the Swift. There is decent amount of room for five and a boot that is large by small car standards. The Swift on the other hand is not as spacious. The rear seats owing to the tall waistline of the car makes you feel like sitting in a cave, but if you are about to say that it gives a sense of security, I’m not arguing. The Swift makes up with better ergonomics and seating postures. The dashboard design of the Swift looks and feels better even though the swooping design makes it less practical. The front seats of both the cars are very comfortable but with a slight difference. In the Swift, the seats hold you tightly in corners, as the car slides. But in the Getz, it is you who will be sliding about, since its seats are larger.The Swift has just 76bhp and 19kg-m of torque against the Getz’s 110bhp and 24kg-m. So the Getz is a rocket dismissing the 0-100kmph run in 11.3 seconds while the Swift gets there about two seconds later, which is also not too bad. But for all that power, Hyundai does not provide ABS even as an option which is pathetic. Surprisingly the Swift is faster in the 20-80kmph run in third gear which shows how driveable the car is. Add to that the instant throttle response of the engine which makes it better to drive in stop and go city traffic. When it comes to ride quality the Swift diesel though better than its petrol counterpart, is no match for the Getz. The Getz can glide over potholes while the Swifts lets you know a little about what is going underneath. But there is a downside to this good ride quality; the Getz does not like the corners. There is a noticeable amount of body roll and the steering lacks feedback but the wider tyres help when it comes to grip. The Swift meanwhile is a taut handler with a thoroughly communicative steering but is otherwise spoilt by tyres that are too skinny for the car’s potential. So if you buy one and plan to drive fast, invest in wider tyres.The Swift itself is a bit overpriced, but compared to the Getz it looks like a bargain. The Swift is about a lakh cheaper than the Getz and it sips diesel through a thinner straw which makes it more fuel efficient-almost 2kmpl more. For the enthusiasts we are, we would have always voted for the faster car, but this is diesel world and economy is the operative word here. Running costs and list price make up the purchase while performance takes the back seat. So the Swift Getz the crown even though the Getz is Swifter.





